‘When Willa turned and kissed her, Louie thought in her head, this is my first kiss. It wasn’t, of course, she’d kissed a number of boys, and done more too, but she’d never, ever felt as if she were falling off a cliff.’Dare Truth or Promise, a turbulent love story by New Zealander Paula Boock, recalls Nancy Garden’s Annie on My Mind and Good Moon Rising in its portrayal of two young women caught up in sexual passion for each other. Louie is the talented daughter of wealthy and cultured parents, and Willa is a strong-minded redhead who lives over the pub. They come from different worlds, but when they meet working at Burger Giant, lightning strikes–soon they are frantically in love. Willa has had a previous affair that was undermined by denial, but this time it feels inevitable and right, even when Louie’s mother banishes Willa after discovering them in an embrace; even when Willa is threatened by hostile anonymous notes; even when they avoid each other in confusion and pain. Thanks to the acceptance of her tough bartender mother, Willa gains the strength to wait it out, but a psychologist tells Louie that her feelings are a passing phase, a fundamentalist promises her sins will land her in hell, and her best friend is supportive but embarrassed. The healing words that finally enable Louie to believe in herself and return to the relationship come at last from a young priest: ‘You see, I think love comes from God. And so, to turn away from love, real love, it could be argued, is to turn away from God.’ (Ages 16 and older) –Patty Campbell
Dare Truth or Promise was published by Longacre Press in Dunedin, New Zealand, in 1997, and by Houghton Mifflin in the United States. Louie, an outstanding student who means to become a lawyer, and Willa, who lives above the pub her mother runs, meet at Woodhaugh Girls' High and fall in love, and have to face their own fears, Louie's mother and the hostility around them to stay together.
The novel won Book of the Year and the Senior Fiction award at the 1998 New Zealand Post Children's Book Awards, and was a finalist for the Lambda Literary Award in the children's and young adult category. Kirkus compared it to Nancy Garden's Annie on My Mind. A twentieth-anniversary tribute in The Sapling recalled a school principal announcing that the library would not stock the winning book, and the writer's own sense that the novel had shown her who she could be.
Comment
Dare Truth or Promise was published by Longacre Press in Dunedin, New Zealand, in 1997, and by Houghton Mifflin in the United States. Louie, an outstanding student who means to become a lawyer, and Willa, who lives above the pub her mother runs, meet at Woodhaugh Girls' High and fall in love, and have to face their own fears, Louie's mother and the hostility around them to stay together.
The novel won Book of the Year and the Senior Fiction award at the 1998 New Zealand Post Children's Book Awards, and was a finalist for the Lambda Literary Award in the children's and young adult category. Kirkus compared it to Nancy Garden's Annie on My Mind. A twentieth-anniversary tribute in The Sapling recalled a school principal announcing that the library would not stock the winning book, and the writer's own sense that the novel had shown her who she could be.